Are per diem nurses cheaper than full-time staff?

Per diem nurses often cost more per hour but carry no benefits load. Learn how to compare the cost of per diem nurses vs. full-time staff.

Manage your shifts at Nursa platform

Add Your Credit Card

Add your credit card to complete setup - once added, your facility will be automatically verified

Skip
A photo of per diem nurses
Written by
Lori Fuqua
December 7, 2026

Key takeaways:

  • Rate vs. real cost: Per diem usually costs more per hour but can cost less per productive hour.
  • Fully loaded cost: A staff nurse’s cost includes benefits, payroll taxes, paid time off, recruiting, and overtime.
  • The formula: Divide a full-time nurse’s annual cost by their productive hours.
  • Breakeven point: Weekly recurring hours usually favor a staff hire, while irregular gaps favor per diem.
  • Setting matters: Contract labor weighs more heavily on skilled nursing facilities than on hospitals.

Per hour, usually not. Per hour of care delivered, often yes. Is that a frustrating answer? Maybe, so let’s go straight to the why:

  • No: A per diem shift usually costs more per hour than a staff nurse’s base pay rate.
  • Yes: Facilities don’t pay benefits, leave, or payroll taxes for independent contractor per diem nurses, and they only pay for the hours worked.

When you assess the cost of per diem nurses vs. full-time staff nurses, look at the big picture—the fully loaded cost per productive hour. Once you have that, ask another question: how often does the scheduling gap come back?

Here’s how to work out what a staff nurse really costs, what a per diem shift costs, where you can break even, and how the math works out in hospitals and skilled nursing facilities.

How do per diem nurse costs compare to full-time staff?

Facilities pay per diem nurses and full-time staff for different things, so a fair comparison is what each costs per hour of care delivered:

  • A staff nurse's cost includes hours that are paid but not worked.
  • A per diem clinician's cost covers only the hours on the unit.

The nurse staffing cost comparison below shows the sources of each model's costs, with agency staffing as a reference.

W-2 full-time staff In-house W-2 PRN pool Per diem independent contractor Agency nurse
What you pay for Wages for every scheduled hour Wages for shifts worked The shift price for each completed shift A bill rate that covers the nurse's pay plus the agency's costs and margin
When you pay Every pay period, whatever the census When pool members work Only when a shift is completed Under contract terms, often with guaranteed hours
Benefits and payroll taxes Paid by the facility Payroll taxes paid by the facility; benefits depend on policy and state law None paid by the facility Built into the bill rate
Paid nonproductive hours Paid time off (PTO), education, orientation, and meetings Usually limited None Built into the bill rate
Recruiting and onboarding Full cost of each hire Hiring cost for each pool member Credential review and first-shift orientation Orientation for each placement
Commitment Ongoing employment Ongoing employment, often with minimum shifts 1 shift or a block of shifts A contract minimum
Scaling down when census drops Limited Moderate Post fewer shifts Limited by notice and cancellation terms

Per diem nurse doesn't mean agency nurse. Much of the per diem vs. agency nurse cost difference comes from what an agency builds into its bill rate and from contract minimums that are billed even when census drops.

How is an in-house PRN pool different from contractors?

An internal PRN pool is made up of the facility's own W-2 employees who work when they're needed. Per diem clinicians on a marketplace are independent contractors (1099) who request shifts at facilities that post them.

The difference in tax status drives most of the 1099 vs. W-2 nurse cost gap. Classification depends on how much control the facility has over the work.

Independent contractors pay their own taxes and benefits.

Alternatively, in-house PRN pool nurses are on the employee payroll, so the facility pays employer payroll taxes on every hour.

Pools often require a minimum number of shifts each scheduling period, and some state laws extend paid sick leave to per diem employees. Running an internal pool also takes management time.

What goes into the fully loaded cost of a staff nurse?

A staff nurse's base wage is only the starting point. The fully loaded cost adds everything the facility pays to keep that nurse on the schedule, including paid hours not spent on patient care.

These are the main components of a fully loaded nurse cost per hour:

  • Wages and differentials: Base pay plus shift, weekend, and specialty differentials.
  • Employer payroll taxes: The employer share of Social Security and Medicare is 7.65% of wages, plus federal and state unemployment taxes.
  • Benefits: Nurse benefits cost includes health coverage, retirement contributions, and other employer-paid benefits. In private-industry hospitals, benefits made up 34.1% of total compensation for professional staff, a group that includes registered nurses (RNs), in June 2026, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). That share counts insurance, retirement, paid leave, overtime, shift premiums, and payroll taxes.
  • Paid nonproductive hours: PTO, education, orientation, and meetings are paid but not spent on the unit or patient care.
  • Recruiting and onboarding: The cost to hire a nurse includes advertising, interviews, credentialing, and orientation, spread over the expected tenure. A plan to shorten the time to productivity for new nurses can help lower that cost.
  • Overtime and turnover exposure: Nurse overtime costs run at least 1.5 times the regular rate, usually for hours over 40 in a workweek, under the Fair Labor Standards Act. Hospitals and residential care facilities can use an 8/80 system instead, which pays overtime after 8 hours in a day or 80 hours in a 14-day period.

When a nurse leaves, the facility pays to replace them, so the cost of nurse turnover belongs in the total as well.

How do you calculate cost per productive hour?

In nursing, productive hours are those worked on the unit, while nonproductive hours are paid hours away from the unit.

Cost per productive hour is the total annual cost of a staff nurse divided by the hours they spend delivering care. That makes it a fair comparison for a per diem shift (only pay for hours worked).

To calculate it:

  1. Add up the annual cost of 1 full-time equivalent (FTE): wages and differentials, payroll taxes, benefits, recruiting and onboarding, and overtime.
  2. Subtract paid nonproductive hours from total paid hours to get productive hours.
  3. Divide the annual cost by the productive hours.

Cost per productive hour = Total annual cost of 1 FTE ÷ (Total paid hours − Paid nonproductive hours)

For example, a nurse who works 12-hour shifts 3 times a week is paid for 1,872 hours a year. If that nurse takes 144 hours of PTO and spends 24 hours in education, they deliver 1,704 productive hours.

Replace these example figures with your own facility's numbers.

What do per diem nurses cost a facility?

A per diem shift costs the price the facility sets, paid only when the shift is completed, plus the internal time required to bring a new clinician onto the unit. Per diem hourly rates are often higher than a staff nurse's base wage, but the facility pays no benefits, payroll taxes, or PTO for independent contractors.

On the Nursa Marketplace, facilities see the shift price before they post and pay only for completed shifts. They can set fixed rates for every shift or use SmartRates, which adjust to demand.

Facilities can post single shifts or shift blocks on the Nursa Marketplace, depending on whether a gap is a single call out or a defined stretch of the calendar.

Which costs stay with the facility?

Per diem nurse staffing costs don't end at the shift price. A few internal costs remain:

  • First-shift orientation: Charge nurse time to walk a new clinician through the unit, the electronic health record (EHR), and the medication system.
  • Credential review: Confirming that each new clinician meets the facility's requirements before their first shift.
  • Scheduling time: Posting shifts, reviewing requests, and confirming who's coming.
  • Continuity: More handoffs when different clinicians rotate through the same unit.

Most of these costs fall on a clinician's first shift, so bringing back per diem clinicians who know the unit can lower them.

On Nursa, facilities can add trusted clinicians to a Favorites List and turn on Auto-Schedule to book those favorites when they request a posted shift.

Shift blocks keep the same clinician on the unit for a set stretch, and Credential Auto-Scan flags what may need a closer look.

Facilities can also share their own training through ShiftReady, so clinicians can complete facility-specific courses before they arrive.

When does per diem cost less than a full-time hire?

Per diem costs less per productive hour when the shift price sits below a staff nurse's fully loaded cost per productive hour, or when hours don't recur often enough to keep a full-time nurse productive. Recurring hours are where a full-time hire usually starts to win.

Deciding when to hire staff vs. use per diem nurses comes down to that price comparison and how many hours of need come back each week.

How do you find your breakeven point?

The breakeven point is where the cost of covering recurring hours with per diem shifts matches the cost of a staff nurse for the same hours. To find it:

  1. Calculate staff cost per productive hour: Use the formula (total annual cost of 1 FTE ÷ productive hours) for the license and unit you're staffing.
  2. Compare it with your per diem shift price: Use the price you post for the same license and unit. (The hourly shift price already is a cost per productive hour)
  3. Count uncovered hours by unit: Pull the last several weeks of open shifts for each unit. Hours that come back on the same days and shifts each week, such as every Saturday night, are recurring. Call outs and census spikes that don't repeat are one-off gaps.
  4. Convert recurring hours into FTEs: A nursing FTE calculation divides recurring weekly hours by the hours in 1 FTE. For example, 36 recurring hours a week equals 1 FTE for a nurse working 12-hour shifts 3 times a week.
  5. Decide: Recurring hours that fill most of an FTE indicate an open position may be worth recruiting for, with per diem just bridging the gap while you recruit. Irregular hours are more indicative of a cost-effective use of per diem staffing.

With Nursa's Central Staffing, schedulers enter pay rates and labor costs, and the platform factors those costs into the schedule so they can compare staffing scenarios using both internal and contingent staff, where appropriate, before the schedule goes live.

Which hidden costs change the math?

Some costs don't appear on a per diem invoice or a payroll line, and they can move your breakeven point in either direction:

  • Overtime displaced: Each per diem shift that covers a gap may replace overtime hours paid at time and a half. Tracking that offset is part of reducing overtime at the unit level.
  • Cost of nurse vacancy: An open shift nobody covers can mean unstaffed beds, delayed admissions, and more strain on the nurses who are there.
  • Continuity of care: On units where residents or patients do better with familiar caregivers, a rotating cast of clinicians carries a cost of its own.

Overtime and vacancy costs usually favor per diem, while continuity usually favors core staff or repeat clinicians.

How does the math change in hospitals and skilled nursing?

The formula stays the same across settings, while wages, benefits load, covered licenses, and staffing reporting change.

The table below compares the same 2 staff groups across hospitals and nursing care facilities, showing what employers paid per hour worked, according to the BLS. 

Paid time off is already folded into that hourly cost, so each total works like a cost per productive hour. However, the totals don't include recruiting, onboarding, or turnover, so your real cost is likely higher. If a per diem shift costs less per hour than your figure, per diem is the cheaper option for those hours.

Employer cost per hour worked, June 2026 Hospitals Nursing care facilities
Management, professional, and related staff; this includes RNs and licensed practical nurses (LPNs) $80.23 (34.1% benefits) $52.50 (25.7% benefits)
Service staff (includes nursing assistants) $36.17 (35.6% benefits) $28.44 (27.4% benefits)

What does a med-surg RN cost per hour?

A medical-surgical (med-surg) RN’s cost per hour depends on your unit’s pay rates. For hospital nurse labor costs, the closest BLS benchmark is the professional staff row in the table above: $80.23 per hour worked in June 2026, with benefits making up 34.1%.

That group includes RNs across hospital units, along with other professional staff, so run the formula with your own unit’s pay rates. A med-surg per diem shift priced below your result costs less per productive hour.

Med-surg gaps often follow seasonal census swings, such as respiratory illness season. Specialty units such as intensive care draw on a smaller pool of qualified nurses, so recruitment for those positions can take longer.

What does an LPN cost per hour in skilled nursing?

To estimate what an LPN costs per hour in skilled nursing, divide your LPN hourly wage by 0.743. Skilled nursing facility (SNF) labor costs often center on LPNs and nursing assistants, with 8-hour shifts more common than in hospitals.

As in the hospital example, the table’s professional staff row is the closest match: $52.50 per hour worked in June 2026, with benefits at 25.7%, compared with 34.1% for the same group in hospitals.

The 0.743 figure is the share of that total paid as wages (100% minus the 25.7% benefits share).

Contract labor costs in healthcare weigh more heavily on SNFs than on hospitals. SNFs also report staffing hours, including contract hours, to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) through Payroll-Based Journal reporting, so changes in the staff and per diem mix are reflected in public staffing measures.

In FY 2024, contract labor was 7.0% of SNF operating expenses, compared with 1.9% for hospitals, according to Nursa's analysis of healthcare labor cost statistics.

How do you turn the cost comparison into a staffing plan?

Assign recurring hours to core staff, variable hours to per diem coverage, and chronic vacancies to recruiting. That split is the core and flex staffing model, and the cost comparison shows where each hour belongs.

  • Building the per diem layer: Building per diem into your staffing model starts with deciding how much of each unit's schedule per diem should cover. Then set a trigger for when a recurring gap becomes an open position. Rebooking a steady group of per diem clinicians can keep orientation time down and give the unit familiar faces.
  • Converting per diem clinicians to staff: Facilities can hire away per diem clinicians they've worked with on the Nursa Marketplace at no fee. Per diem shifts can work well as a working interview for nurses you may want on staff. Facilities can also post Permanent Positions on their Nursa facility profile. 
  • Tracking whether the mix works: Watch fill rate, overtime hours, and per diem share by unit using these healthcare staffing metrics.

Compare per diem and staff nurse costs before you schedule

The cost of per diem nurses vs. full-time staff comes down to 2 things: cost per productive hour and how often the hours recur. Per diem usually wins on irregular gaps, and staff usually win on hours that come back every week.

With Central Staffing, schedulers enter pay rates and labor costs, compare staffing scenarios before the schedule goes live, and cover remaining gaps through the Nursa Marketplace without leaving the platform.

Sources:

FAQs

Lori Fuqua
Blog published on:
December 7, 2026

Lori Fuqua is a senior editor and contributing writer at Nursa, specializing in clinician education, healthcare staffing insights, and regulatory content.

Ready to Get Started?
Begin Posting Shifts on Nursa

Facilities who use Nursa fill 3 times as many open per diem shifts, on average, compared to trying to fill the shifts themselves.
Start posting jobs and shifts today.

Sign Up

Featured Articles

Trusted by 4,500+ Facilities, 31 states and counting
Legacy Village Logo
Intermountain Healthcare Logo
Life care Centers Of America Logo
Image.
Cascadia Healthcare Logo
Image.
Briefcase purple icon

Join 4,500+ Facilities

The smartest facilities use Nursa to fill in shifts in 31 states and counting. Join to get staffing solutions now.

Sign Up
Building Purple Icon

Post Your Jobs Today

Facilities who use Nursa fill 3 times as many open per diem shifts, on average, compared to trying to fill the shifts themselves.

Post Jobs